brewmasters
JERRY BECK
bio & contact
view posts by jerry
AMID AMIDI
bio & contact
view posts by amid
Avatar vs. Delgo V.2
by jerry
August 26, 2009 12:15 pm


File this under “People who don’t know when to quit while they’re ahead”: The producers of Delgo - the biggest bomb of 2008 - are considering a lawsuit against James Cameron over the similarities between their film and his Avatar.

(Cue the laughter).

(Thanks, Mark Mayerson)

08/26/09  12:32pm

This could be a smart move (publicity wise), and while I don’t think they can go anywhere legally, this may help build the cult status of Delgo.

08/26/09  12:46pm
Kevin Martinez says:

Everything about the Avatar/Delgo thing is ludicrous. The alleged stolen elements are things that were old in the days of ancient Greek literature.

08/26/09  1:06pm
creepy says:

it s surprising that they have similarities. I’m sure its coincidence. needless to say it is brilliant for this to happen and breath life into Delgo. one way or another Delgo is going to get more cash because of the similarities.

08/26/09  1:11pm
matt says:

Oh brother. Are they going to sue the descendants of John Smith and Pocahontas too? And all the other million “he learned their ways as if he were born to them and in time led them (usually an American that does this)” stories & films that follow that archetypical form? Jay-zus! Leave “Dances with Thundersmurfs” alone, ya leeches. I realise you’re just trying to claw back some of the money but the horse is dead man, stop whacking it.

It would be cool though if this retrograde action caused a chain reaction of every earlier film suing the next, sorta like an auto pile-up…

08/26/09  1:18pm
startend says:

No. Just no.

08/26/09  1:18pm
Jose Manuel says:

in my opinion avatar looks more like fernguly the last rain forest rather than delgo!

08/26/09  1:20pm

It’s a real shame they don’t have any clear thinking at the studio that made Delgo. Because at this point they could have said something useful like “This is a fucking stupid idea!”.

08/26/09  1:29pm
ack says:

@Ryan
Lawsuits are never a smart move publicity wise.

08/26/09  3:10pm
Well says:

I just want to make it known this is not the unanimous opinion of Fathom. One of the main creators of the film had no idea this was being considered until it was online. It is very likely to be a greatly mis-worded press release, and hopefully nothing will come of it.

I don’t know what happened with Delgo, and like others, didn’t care for it myself. That being said, I really nope no other animator’s personal efforts will have to undergo the smug bullying that this film went through by the very people who should be supporting the idea of independent animation.

08/26/09  3:19pm
Doofus says:

Had they been smart and done something better looking in terms of character design….and animation….they could’ve had something…. now it’s just kinda’ awkward.

08/26/09  3:51pm
Iain says:

Does this spell, ‘Desperate promotion’?

08/26/09  5:12pm
Some Chick says:

“Dances with Thundersmurfs” - Matt

Dang, and I’d been calling it “Ferngully: the Spirits Within”.

08/26/09  6:06pm
Adam says:

You know, when I was telling my girlfriend about the trailer, she couldn’t figure out what I was trying to say - till I said, “Imagine Delgo if Delgo didn’t SUCK, and was directed by James Cameron.” And she said, “Oh, wow, that could be great.”

Heh, Dances with Thundersmurfs. Perfect. Mighty whitey is gonna go and out-alien the aliens!

08/26/09  6:22pm

This story could end up selling more copies of Delgo…mission accomplished!

08/26/09  8:16pm
juanma says:

Heres my opinion
you guys tell me what u think

Avatar Still looks bad.

Delgo looked bad too.

Law suit is stupid tho.

Next thing you know Stan Lee is suing Brad Bird for the Incredibles

08/26/09  9:30pm
Fred Cline says:

It’s hard to “quit while you’re ahead” if you’ve never been ahead!

08/27/09  1:08am
greg manwaring says:

Guess I should sue too!!

I came up with a similar concept around ‘96 and pitched it to Roland Emmerich in 2004. He had to pass because his buddy James Cameron was preparing to make a similar type film.

These things simply happen… …those guys should just be happy their film came out.

08/27/09  3:22am

FAKE!
The internet has the most appallingly under equipped critical faculties. And yes, I’m talking about Brew readers.

James Cameron spends years talking about this deal-breaker of a picture, that is supposed to define effects movies for the next decade - and when it turns up, its just another (albeit more expensive) entry into that peculiar genre that houses Delgo, Battle for Tera or a host of other such productions that dance on the borders of competency and which no one has heard of.

One of the dominating publicity vacuums of next year, promises to be another trip to Uncanny Valley that will further muddy the path for good cartooning - and no one has anything to say about this? Instead the internet considers the appropriate response to this, is to call cheat on Mr Cameron!? Woods for the VUE 8 trees, people?

James Cameron makes the worst series of creative decisions since John Lasseter put the eyes on the windshield, and all internet can think to do is call cheat on where the man got his terrible ideas from.

Internet should be ashamed of itself.

08/27/09  7:12am
christian says:

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

haha

08/27/09  7:28am
Peter says:

Even if Delgo didn’t outright suck and were directed by James Cameron, that wouldn’t get my hopes up. At the end of the day, Avatar still feels like a video game intro. If Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within didn’t work, why would this?

08/27/09  9:56am
I says:

I have a bias against characters with long philtrums. With the exception of E.T.

08/27/09  11:30am
Andy says:

Remember, Cameron also made “Piranah 2″. Just sayin’…

08/28/09  1:11pm
TheGunheart says:

Wait, wait, wait…Tony, did you just dis Susie the Little Blue Coupe?

Frankly, I prefer the eyes on the windshield. It spaces the eyes from the mouth (bumper), allowing the hood to serve as a nose. It gives it a cute, almost animal-like appearance that I find MUCH more appealing than the creepy headlight eyes configuration or the dreaded “hood mouth”.

08/28/09  7:34pm

LOL Any money that the Delgo guys could get from Cameron, would then be taken by Disney, for illegal use of character design :-P

09/5/09  4:08pm
Vvek says:

from what i heard - i thought it was proven, that delgo createors were once on the avatar team & delgo was nothing but a revenge project.

Write a comment.





Comment: