editors
JERRY BECK (LA)
AMID AMIDI (NY)
The Lost Tribes of New York City
by amid
March 26, 2009 3:39 am


Filmmakers Andy and Carolyn London (A Letter to Colleen) interviewed people around New York City and transposed their voices onto inanimate objects. The result could be likened to a grittier (and more disturbing) version of Creature Comforts. Andy told me that to covertly record the two drunks who appear in the short, he had to slouch down on the ground next to them in Penn Station and act drunk while pretending to listen to music. I think it was well worth the effort.

| Trackback URI

Richard Gaines says:
03/26/09  4:24am

Ha! Ha! I loved it!! It seemed so natural.

 
Patrick Smith says:
03/26/09  5:03am

Brilliant. Carolyn and Andy seem to be getting better with each short they produce. Their style is so experimental, in the true sense of the term. They are not dedicated to a single medium.. they jump around from clay, stop motion, cut out, live action roto, to THIS. keeps us all wanting more, and wondering what will come next! Nice work !!!

 
Mitch K says:
03/26/09  5:08am

Totally awesome. :D

 
Gobo says:
03/26/09  5:26am

I love their technique and style, but I feel like they could’ve put more thought into what objects they were using. A lot of the humor of Creature Comforts came from the way they perfectly paired animals with what the interviewees were talking about (pigs talking about cleanliness, etc). When you’ve got a bright-red traffic post talking about how proud she is that she’s black, you lose that completely. Where’s the humor in a telephone talking about his love of street music? Why not a boombox?

 
Sam E says:
03/26/09  6:15am

Too bad it’s not executed well.

 
Gui says:
03/26/09  7:29am

That’s really nice.

 
Tim Rauch says:
03/26/09  7:36am

Andy and Carolyn have already shown themselves to be brilliant writers, and it’s great to see them working with “found sound” here. Bravo! This thing had the ASIFA-East jury rolling in their seats last week.

 
Nate Milton says:
03/26/09  8:20am

SOOOOOOO good. damn. I’m inspired.

 
Dave says:
03/26/09  9:03am

This is a fresh update on what Bakshi did in “Fritz the Cat”, using real people he recorded in a Harlem bar. John Hubley also did it with his own kids in the 1950’s. It always works because real people on the track so seldom occurs in animation, a medium bogged down by narcissistic voice actors and lately major move stars working for hideous upfront bucks severely impacting the production budget.

 
Victor says:
03/26/09  11:55am

God i love New York! Awesome!

 
Elliot Cowan says:
03/26/09  11:58am

I say give a hale and hearty “HUZZAH!” to this film.

 
Paul N says:
03/26/09  1:40pm

Very cool, although I wonder why it’s been described as “disturbing.”

 
David Levy says:
03/26/09  2:51pm

A very creative film… Andy and Caroline London are very exciting filmmakers. And, I admire their commitment to spinning out a neat new film every year.

 
Anne says:
03/27/09  9:21am

I like when such creative people make us discover new ways of talking about town ! These ones are very clever and poetic !

 
linda beck says:
04/6/09  8:11am

Creative, simple, and well-executed. One of my favourites from the ASIFA east Jury Screenings.

 
Name: (required)
E-mail: (never shown publicly, but comments without working address will be deleted)
Website
Comment: