Oscar Ballot Guide: ‘The Tale of The Princess Kaguya’ Acting and Performance Analysis

hooks_kaguya_main

Series Introduction

The 2015 Oscar nominees for Best Animated Feature are, in alphabetical order: Big Hero 6, How to Train Your Dragon 2, Song of the Sea, The Boxtrolls, and The Tale of the Princess Kaguya. It’s an interesting and varied field, with a high level of craft on display throughout. Over the next two weeks, I will present a performance analysis for each of these films, beginning today with Isao Takahata’s hand-drawn film Princess Kaguya.

I am an acting teacher, not a movie reviewer, and my intended reader is the animation professional, not the general public. My goal is to help elevate the art of feature animation above merely commercial considerations. Box office grosses, no matter how impressive, are not a factor in my analyses. I am interested only in how a film works aesthetically—whether it is emotionally satisfying, cohesively expressed, and dynamically constructed. Where possible in these analyses, I will include thumbnail acting principles to illuminate particular comments or observations.

The Tale of the Princess Kaguya

Hayao Miyazaki was asked once during an interview what was the difference between his style of animation and animation in the West. He thought about it for a moment and then began to rhythmically clap his hands as he answered.

“When I clap my hands,” he said, “you hear the sound of the clap. You don’t hear what is in between the sound of the clap. In Japan, we have a name for what is in between the sound of the clap. We call it ma like ‘ma-ma.’” Miyazaki continued speaking, while clapping slowly: “Western animators are afraid of ma. They think you have to keep making the sound of the clap, or you will lose your audience. I disagree; I think if you fill ma with thinking, emotion and intention, you will not lose your audience.”

Studio Ghibli’s The Tale of the Princess Kaguya, based on a 10th century Japanese folk tale, has plenty of ma and the tale itself is incomplete, with hints of magic. Even after screening it several times, I still can’t tell you for certain why the character Li’l Bamboo shows up one morning as a thumb-sized child inside a freshly cut stalk of bamboo because director Isao Takahata is not explicit on the point. The character is just suddenly…there. The old bamboo cutter cuts a random stalk, and there she is, that’s all, a tiny beautiful jewel of a character. We in the audience are asked to willingly suspend our disbelief in such events, and so we do easily.

The principle of willingly suspending disbelief is an important one and is often abused in big Hollywood animated movies. An audience will go anywhere the storyteller asks it to, just as long as the rules for pretending are established up front. In Disney’s Pinocchio, for example, the movie opens on a cricket talking, singing, reading from a book, while wearing a dapper costume. We know perfectly well that crickets do none of these things in the real world, but the storyteller lets us know that this story is going to be one in which that kind of thing does happen. We go along with it, suspending our disbelief, and when the wooden puppet comes to life a few minutes later, we do not for an instant question the reality of it because the parameters of our suspension of disbelief were set up front, by Jiminy Cricket.

The Tale of the Princess Kaguya is clearly a folk tale. Humans do not hatch from bamboo stalks. Nonetheless, the storyteller is asking us to pretend that it is possible–just for the purposes of the tale being told. And so we do, happily, go along. In another film contending for an Oscar this year, How to Train Your Dragon 2, the suspension of disbelief is more complicated. We accept that there were pet dragons back in Viking days, but when Stoick finds Hiccup’s tiny helmet in the vast expanse of an uncharted icy ocean, we roll our eyes a bit because finding the helmet is too neat and tidy—a coincidence. There is no charm or artfulness in the finding of that helmet, only screenwriting expediency.

hooks_kaguya_e

You have to be a grown-up to appreciate a children’s story like The Tale of the Princess Kaguya, and for better or worse, I personally fit the demographic. This is a story about paths not taken in life, about the simple wisdom of living fully in the present moment. Even though its title is The Tale of the Princess Kaguya, this is actually the old bamboo cutter’s story. Princess Kaguya’s appearance is the instigating event that leads the bamboo cutter to confront the Big Questions in Life.

There are images and moments in this film that have stayed with me days after watching it, When the bamboo cutter realizes that his adopted daughter is really leaving, he falls to his knees in bitter, flush-face, snot-running tears. (Timecode: 1:50:14 from the screener DVD.) Regret looks like that, and the moment made me cry, too, and still does if I even think of it.

This is what Shakespeare was talking about when he advised, in Hamlet, that “the actor hold up the mirror to nature.” Takahata is a great artist, and it is apparent from this single image. A lesser artist might have shown the bamboo cutter’s sadness with tears, but Takahata extended the action. As I explain in my acting classes for animators, emotion tends to lead to action, and the degree of the action is an artist’s expression. Tears alone would have communicated sadness and distress, but falling on his knees and copiously weeping like this is far more powerful. Good performance requires that the artist have courage as well as insight. Takahata could have gone too far when he pushed the impulse, but he did not. He was firmly in control of the moment, an artist in his world.

Let’s look at a few other specific sequences, analyzing them for performance:

hooks_kaguya_a

11:51 – 13:37 In this sequence, neighborhood kids are teasing the young girl, because she is growing so fast. It embarrasses her a bit, but the taunts set up the moment when the bamboo cutter comes to her defense. “Li’l Bamboo! Li’l Bamboo! Li’l Bamboo!” they chant. But the old bamboo cutter defends and protects her, reassuring her that she is a true princess. Again, the acting principle is that emotion tends to lead to action, so when the child jumps excitedly into the bamboo cutter’s protective embrace, we in the audience see the action and then, with empathy, look under the action to find the emotion that led to it. That is how empathy works in acting. We see what a character does, and then we look for the motivation. It all happens in a heartbeat, but you can see it if you slow down and investigate your own personal mental responses to good performance.

15:15 – 16:28 She stops in the woods to play with a litter of piglets and, when mama pig charges the intruder, the boy named Sutemaru rushes in and recues Li’l Bamboo just in time. A lifetime bond is formed that, in more ideal circumstances, would lead to marriage, children, and a life together. It is an innocent, sweet moment that is poignant in hindsight. Note, in particular, how emotion drives the entire sequence. Note Sutemaru’s urgency when he rushes in. That is a factor of emotion, not reasoning.

hooks_kaguya_c

21:46 – 24:35 Li’l Bamboo unselfconsciously goes skinny dipping with her friends. Note how you, the audience, waits for Li’l Bamboo’s emotions after she is nude. Is she embarrassed? No. Many girls her age would be modest at this moment. We see something special about this character. Also, it is significant that she is totally nude. Takahata could have strategically covered her, and it was a pure artistic choice to have her stand nude for all to see. Later that day, she and Sutemaru steal a ripe melon from a local melon patch. They hide in the brush as he slices it up and they giggle and drool, enjoying one of the most delicious experiences in their young lives.

31:15 – 32:10 Without warning, her parents instruct Li’l Bamboo to leave her friends and carefree life and to come with them to the city. Disappointed and confused, she does what they ask her to do. Acting note: Observe the emotional transition. When she realizes she must abandon her friends, she is sad. The sadness is what leads to her rather wooden movement as she accompanies her parents. She is covering sadness; the covering itself is an action. In an instant, her life changes, and we arrive at the first major transitional moment in the movie. Note the change in the bamboo cutter’s posture as he adopts what he believes is upper-class carriage. He is calling all the shots in this life transition, with his wife and daughter following his lead.

40:39 – 43:08 Li’l Bamboo has her first menses, a sad moment for her, but an occasion of great joy and celebration for the bamboo cutter whose attention now shifts to finding for his daughter a wealthy and hopefully royal husband. Very nice performance animation here. The girl has mixed emotions about having her period. She realizes that she is a woman now, that time is passing, childhood is fading behind her. That is what causes her to eagerly suggest that she invite her old friends to the party. She is trying to hang on to childhood. A bittersweet moment that should resonate for all women. When her father rejects her suggestion with, “Don’t be a fool! We live in a different world to those hillbillies!” she realizes that a door has been violently slammed shut in her life.

hooks_kaguya_b

Good acting does not necessarily equate to a lot of movement.

48:44 In this sequence, Li’l Bamboo, now formally re-named as the Princess Kaguya (“Shining Light”), seems to become a living—but literal—doll. They pluck her eyebrows, stain her teeth (“a fine lady does not open her mouth to laugh”) and dress her in exotic gowns. The life is going out of her as we watch. Acting note: Seeming to become a living doll is an acting choice. She does not want to fight it any more, even though she hates the idea of having her eyebrows plucked. When you see her so physically still, so compliant, that is an acting choice. Good acting does not necessarily equate to a lot of movement. If you think about it, some of the most important crossroad moments in your life have been quite still physically.

Five high-born men seek Princess Kaguya’s hand in marriage, and she rejects them all. The Emperor Mikado himself hears of this great beauty and courts her unsuccessfully. The movie feels overlong at times, and this is the reason why. If you have seen one thwarted, 10th century high-born suitor, you have seen them all. Isao Takahata respects his source material too much to tamper much with it, but in this case a couple high-born suitors, plus the Mikado, would have been more than sufficient.

hooks_kaguya_d

1:47:10 Princess Kaguya tells her parents that she is leaving them soon, returning to the moon. It distresses her when the bamboo cutter tries to make her feel guilty about leaving, but she chooses not to engage with him on that level. “Everything we’ve done has been for your happiness,” he says tearfully. “That happiness you wished for me was hard to bear,” she replies, explaining that she prayed to the moon to save her. The acting note once again is that emotion tends to lead to action. And so, one final time, Li’l Bamboo reunites with Sutemaru who is now married with a child of his own. Seeking him out, going to his side, was a powerful acting choice. The easy thing would be to go on her way, leaving the Earth the way she found it. But all of us have an impulse to complete actions. It is in our nature that we put a final period on our activities when we can.

2:00:21 In a fantasy sequence, Li’l Bamboo and Sutemaru fly away. The final image of them together, before she falls permanently back into the orbit of the moon, is a fully-clothed but clearly intimate full-body lovers’ embrace, a wedding bed scene that is never to be. I recommend that you pause the film right there if you are watching it on a DVD. Pause it with them in loving embrace. Now…be honest: How do you feel?

These are just some of the sequences in Princess Kaguya that knock me out. It’s a stunningly beautiful piece of art that almost defies description and a film that I hope you will see. Isao Takahata is an animation master.


ED HOOKS is the author of Acting for Animators, (revised third edition, Routledge, 2011). Ed pioneered Acting for Animators in 1998 while working with the animators at PDI/DreamWorks in northern California, and teaches the Acting for Animators masterclass internationally. For Cartoon Brew, he previously wrote a performance analysis of Disney’s Frozen. For more information about his practice, visit EdHooks.com


  • http://www.alex-loayza.com/ Chickengirl

    I don’t expect it to win the Oscar, so far it seems like HTTYD 2 might win it, which was also a good film, but I haven’t been so emotionally moved by a animated movie in a such a long time after I saw Kaguya. It truly was a work of art, it had it’s flaws here and there, but what an incredible film. Viewing it was a very bittersweet experience for me, because I knew that it performed poorly in Japan, it’s Takahata’s last film, and now with studio ghibli ceasing their feature film production after When Marine Was there, we won’t get another film like this from them ever again. Plus with 2D animated feature films becoming so scarce now, you could go as far to say that Kaguya is one of the last of it’s kind.

    Unless they decide to go back to making feature films later on, but I doubt it :(

    There was an entire documentary made about this film, but it’s in Japanese DVD format only and I don’t think it comes with english subtitles, which is a real shame, because the other ghibli documentary that came out recently, The Kingdom of Dreams and Madness, mostly focused on Miyazaki and the production of the Wind Rises, Takahata barely got any screen time at all.

    • LLJ

      Chickengirl, there will be an 82 minute documentary included as an extra on the upcoming North American Blu-Ray release, which is presumably what you are referring to.
      So, Takahata will get his due on it.

      • http://jadering.blogspot.com J.R.D.S. aka Turtleheart ♥

        You’re right: in Japan it’s only available on video separately (as an extended 201-minute cut, without English subtitles) so GKIDS have really scored one in being allowed to bundle it with the so-usually stripped-back US release, even if it is “only” the 82-minute theatrical cut. (Will therefore be annoying for me if this turns out to be region A-locked like “Poppy Hill” is…)

        • Doug

          Forgive my thick headedness – but am I reading that GKIDS will distribute the feature as well as the documentary on Takahata for dvd release in the U.S.? If so, that is VERY good news.

    • Lam

      The problem, I hear is that Academy members can vote even without seeing all the nominees. But I agree with you, this is one of the best movie I’ve seen in a few years. I’ve seen HTTYD, Lego, Big Hero six, they’re good and fun movies but Kaguya is one level above them almost as good as a Kurosawa.

  • sjur

    If the Oscar committee has any integrity at all, they will give this film the award. But they don’t.

  • http://thedavecartershow.com/ Dave Carter

    Very cool Ed Hooks. Look forward to more.

  • UsaMiKo

    This is really interesting to read, because for a long time I’d been wondering if there was any particular core difference between how American animators approach animation and how Japanese animators do . There are so many cultural differences in our body languages, reactions, and the other ways we act in everyday situations that you’d think it could be hard to read and fully understand a movie from the other side. I guess it’s movies like this that show you that that cultural boundaries can be overcome if done right.

    • UsaMiKo

      Edit:”… how American animators approach ACTING…” is what I had meant to say. Sorry about that.

  • Lauren Sparks

    Excellent observations, thank you Ed Hooks! I have noticed that Japanese animation gives much more screen time to let the moments breathe, to take in visuals. (Japanese comics also do this, giving a very different feel than American comics.) Miyazaki’s “ma” example that describes this is just PERFECT.

    Thank you for these insights!!

  • http://tresportfolio.tumblr.com/ Tres Swygert

    This analysis is very well thought out, and takes its time to deliver the major key points for why The Tale of Princess Kaguya is a great film. I really enjoyed this read Ed, and I look forward to reading more from you when you post. Thanks for sharing your insight and wisdom.

  • http://jadering.blogspot.com J.R.D.S. aka Turtleheart ♥

    One correction: “The Tale of the Bamboo Cutter” is not a folk tale, but quite the opposite: it is the first (surviving, at least) original prose fiction written in Japanese. I can forgive Mr. Hooks or anyone else that confusion given how it’s been propagated by the movie’s press material, just not whosoever translated that – somehow, from “日本最古の物語文学”, which quite literally and specifically means “oldest Japanese literary tale”, they arrived at “ancient Japanese folktale”.

    That Miyazaki anecdote is a gem I hadn’t come across before. And now this may be my own misinterpretation, but to me it extends to comparing the intelligence or not that’s assumed of mainstream audiences by the Japanese and anglophone entertainment industries (the key difference between them before anything specific to animation) and what the early UPA theatrical shorts did in comparison with the dominant classical “bladder of water” style (“The Wind Rises” actually felt very filled-in animation-wise; rather too much so for planes and people rather than the fish and water of “Ponyo” for my liking). What frustrates me most about Disney then and now is their seeming terrified of doing anything which could be misinterpreted as cutting back, even when it would be the more artistically effective option – which is a shame when they’ve many of the world’s best animators and concept artists in their employ (of course they had that blatantly cut-back xeroxed era in-between, but that’s enough tangency for one comment). Looking forward to subsequent entries in this series; I’m even more interested to read those for the one I’ve already seen for comparison with my thoughts, and those I’ve no plan to for the informed opinion on what they do achieve.

    • Steven Bowser

      I think by “folktale” everyone probably means that it’s like a fairytale, like Thumbelina is. It’s a fantastical make believe story that’s been passed down for generations. That’s how I understood it at least.

  • Chowder Man

    I’m a “general public” audience member, and I have no trouble understanding this detailed analysis of the film. Rather condescending to automatically expect a “general public” member to not understand the nuances of the film eh?

    • Steven Bowser

      I think “general public” will never hear about this website, or even hear about The Tale of Princess Kayuga. Most people don’t really take the time to even care about how animation is done, and how much variety there is besides Spongebob and Disney. Sad, but true.

  • hitface

    I know this wasnt intended for non animators, but i really enjoyed reading this. i already love the art and thought put into animated movies but this makes me appreciate it even more. animation and illustration are quite powerful abilities. so many stories to be told in so many different ways.

  • Steven Bowser

    I haven’t yet seen Song of the Sea (I’m super excited for it), Big Hero 6, or the Boxtrolls, but I still can’t help but feel like this film deserves the most praise. It isn’t a children’s movie, it truly is a work of art. It’s good in almost every way, and (correct me if I’m wrong) it’s Takahata’s swan song as well.